Columbia Arcadia II Best Overall
- Hood
- Adjustable
- Sizing
- Standard and extended fit
- Packing
- Packable
- Waterproofing
- Fully waterproof
Fully waterproof and packable at the same time is a rarer combination than the shelf suggests, and that pairing is why the Arcadia II is the jacket we hand to most people. It is a plain hooded shell with nothing to figure out, and it is the quietest waterproof jacket we wore — no tarp rustle on a long walk, which matters more than it sounds like it should.
The deciding details are the ones that get you through an actual wet day. The hood cinches down far enough to cover your face instead of sliding back off your head, the front zip sits behind a hook-and-loop flap that shuts out wind as well as rain, and the wrist tabs close over gloves. Water beads up and rolls off the surface rather than soaking in, and through long, steady soaks it stayed dry inside.
What it is not is a winter coat. There is no insulation, so in real cold it becomes a shell over a hoodie or a fleece, which is exactly how we wore it through a wet fall. It is light enough to forget you are carrying it and structured enough to look intentional over a sweater, and Columbia offers it in extended sizes, so a close cut does not shut anyone out.
The color range deserves a mention too — there are enough shades that wearing the same jacket every wet day does not feel like a uniform. It folds into a tote or a daypack without a fight and goes back on without a crease, which is why it lives by the door rather than in a closet.
What We Like
- Beads off steady rain instead of soaking through
- Quiet fabric, no tarp rustle on a walk
- Adjustable hood that pulls over your face
- Packs into a daypack or tote
Worth Noting
- Runs small through the chest and shoulders
- No interior pocket for keys or a phone
This is the rain jacket most people should buy: fully waterproof, quiet, light enough to carry, and priced with the middle of the field. Size up if you layer.
Check Latest Price